Easy homemade dog and cat toys: amazing DIY fun

Lula Thompson

On 5/24/2025, 11:14:22 PM

Make fun, easy homemade dog and cat toys using simple materials you already have!

Table of Contents

Ever watch your dog demolish a brand-new squeaky toy in under five minutes? Or perhaps your cat gives that expensive feathered wand a single, dismissive sniff before walking away? Pet toys can be surprisingly pricey, and their lifespan often feels inversely proportional to the cost. You might wonder if there’s a better way to keep your furry companions entertained without emptying your wallet.

Why Make Homemade Dog and Cat Toys?

Why Make Homemade Dog and Cat Toys?

Why Make Homemade Dog and Cat Toys?

Beyond the Pet Store Sticker Shock

Let's be honest, walking into a pet store can feel like entering a luxury car dealership sometimes. Those fancy interactive puzzles and plush toys with five different squeakers? They come with price tags that make you wince. And often, they don't last much longer than a commercial break, especially if you have a power chewer or a determined shredder. Making homemade dog and cat toys cuts right through that. You're using materials you might already have, like old t-shirts or scrap fabric, drastically reducing the cost. It’s about getting creative with what's available instead of constantly shelling out for things designed to be destroyed.

Tailored Fun and Safety First

Another big win for homemade dog and cat toys? You know exactly what goes into them. No mystery plastics, no questionable dyes, no stuffing that looks suspiciously like packing peanuts. You pick the materials, ensuring they are safe and appropriate for your pet's size and play style. Got a cat who loves chasing crinkle balls? You can make a dozen for the price of one store-bought. Have a dog who lives for tug-of-war? A braided fleece rope is tough and washable. It’s a level of customization you just don’t get off the shelf, and it means you can avoid common hazards found in some mass-produced toys.

So, why bother with homemade dog and cat toys?

  • Save serious money compared to buying new toys constantly.
  • Customize toys for your pet's specific needs and preferences.
  • Control the materials for better safety.
  • Reduce waste by repurposing old items.
  • It's a fun, simple activity you can do with minimal supplies.

Simple DIY Homemade Dog and Cat Toys from Fleece

Simple DIY Homemade Dog and Cat Toys from Fleece

Simple DIY Homemade Dog and Cat Toys from Fleece

The Magic of Fleece Scraps

Fleece is your new best friend when it comes to homemade dog and cat toys. Why? It’s soft, it’s durable enough for many pets, and it doesn’t fray when you cut it. That last part is huge – no annoying little threads coming loose for pets to swallow. You can often find fleece scraps at fabric stores for cheap, or even better, repurpose old fleece blankets or clothing that are headed for the donation bin or the trash. Making simple DIY homemade dog and cat toys from fleece is incredibly straightforward, requiring little more than some fabric and scissors. It’s the perfect starting point for anyone new to pet toy crafting.

Two Go-To Fleece Toys: Tug Ropes and Crinkle Poms

Let's start simple. For dogs who love to tug, a braided fleece rope is a classic. Cut three long strips of fleece, maybe 1 to 2 inches wide depending on your dog's size and chewing power. Tie a knot at one end, braid the strips tightly, and tie another knot at the other end. Trim the ends to make them neat. That’s it. For cats, a simple pom-pom with a crinkle element is often a winner. Cut several squares of fleece. Stack them up. Make parallel cuts from the edge towards the center, leaving a solid middle strip. Lay a piece of crinkly material (like from a clean snack bag, but be careful it's not something they'll ingest) on the solid strip. Tie a long piece of fleece tightly around the middle, over the crinkle material, to hold it all together and create the pom-pom shape. You can leave the long tie piece to hang the toy.

  • Fleece doesn't fray, making it safer for pets.
  • Old fleece blankets or clothes work perfectly.
  • Tug ropes are great for dogs who love to pull.
  • Crinkle poms appeal to cats' love for sound.
  • Both toys require minimal materials and skill.

Turning Household Items into Fun Pet Toys

Turning Household Items into Fun Pet Toys

Turning Household Items into Fun Pet Toys

Cardboard, Bottles, and the Joy of Destruction

Before you toss that empty paper towel roll or the slightly-crushed plastic water bottle, pause. These aren't just trash; they're potential goldmines for homemade dog and cat toys. A simple cardboard tube can become a treat dispenser for a cat – just fold the ends in and poke a few holes. Drop some kibble inside and watch them work for it. For dogs, an empty plastic bottle (remove the cap and ring!) inside an old sock can provide satisfying crunching sounds. It's cheap, it's easy, and frankly, watching a dog gleefully crinkle a bottle inside a sock is far more entertaining than you'd think. Just make sure they aren't actually eating the plastic.

Old Clothes, New Purpose

Raid your closet for items past their prime. That t-shirt with the mysterious stain? The sock that lost its partner? They're perfect for making homemade dog and cat toys. Cut an old t-shirt into strips and braid it into a tug toy, similar to the fleece one. Socks can be stuffed with other fabric scraps or even empty water bottles for a quick, crinkly chew toy. For cats, an old t-shirt sleeve can be stuffed with a bit of batting and catnip, then tied off. It’s recycling with a furry, purring, or tail-wagging bonus. You're giving new life to textiles destined for landfill and saving cash.

  • Empty paper towel or toilet paper rolls: Great as treat puzzles for cats.
  • Clean plastic bottles (lids and rings removed): Provide satisfying crunch for dogs when placed inside a sock.
  • Old t-shirts: Cut and braided into tug toys or stuffed for chew toys.
  • Single socks: Stuff with fabric scraps or bottles.
  • Cardboard boxes: Simple, temporary fun for cats to explore and hide in.

Safety First: What to Watch Out for in Homemade Pet Toys

Safety First: What to Watch Out for in Homemade Pet Toys

Safety First: What to Watch Out for in Homemade Pet Toys

More Than Just Fun: Avoiding Hazards

Alright, so you've got your fleece scraps and old t-shirts ready. That's great! But before you start knotting and stuffing everything in sight, let's pump the brakes for a second. Making homemade dog and cat toys is awesome, but it comes with a significant responsibility: safety. A store-bought toy usually goes through some kind of testing (though maybe not enough, honestly). Your DIY creation? That's entirely on you. We're talking about avoiding choking hazards, indigestible materials, and anything that could cause injury. Think about how your pet plays – are they gentle chewers or do they treat toys like a personal vendetta? This dictates what materials and constructions are safe. Small buttons, plastic eyes, loose strings, or anything that can easily break off and be swallowed are absolute no-gos. That satisfying crinkle bottle? Make sure the cap and plastic ring are gone, and the sock is thick enough that they can't chew through to the plastic itself and ingest pieces.

Wrapping Up Your DIY Pet Projects

So there you have it. Crafting homemade dog and cat toys doesn't require a workshop or a trust fund. It's about using what's available, understanding what makes your pet tick, and maybe saving a few bucks in the process. These simple projects offer a practical alternative to the often-flimsy or overpriced options on the market. Remember to keep an eye on wear and tear – no toy is indestructible, store-bought or otherwise. Providing engaging toys is part of the deal when you bring a pet home, and sometimes the best solution is the one you make yourself.